Unexpectedly, Thad MacArthur comes back into Eve Cassidyis life after breaking her heart in college. This time, however, Eve is different. After much soul-searching, Eve has a whole new approach to her dating relationships. Now, they must decide whether they can put their rocky past behind them to build a future together. As Eve and Thad struggle to make these important choices, they are influenced by two other couples who are also dealing with significant relationship issues. Matt and Liza must confront a mistake from their past that will affect their futures and try to determine if they are really compatible for life. As each couple faces these decisions of love and life, they finally realize that the right person is out there if they simply wait their turn.